Scores and Comments
19.c.pr.105.670
Urban League of Broward County, Incorporated
Application Details |
|
---|---|
Proposal Type | Specific Cultural Project - Discipline-Based |
Request Amount |
$25,000
|
Total Score | 610.000 |
Average Score | 87.143 |
Panelist Scores
Panelist | Excellence | Impact | Management | Accessibility | Total |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Clercx Byron | 36 | 24 | 19 | 10 | 89 |
Dodds Jed | 30 | 25 | 15 | 8 | 78 |
Harder Lee Ellen | 37 | 27 | 18 | 10 | 92 |
Krivinchuk Jeremiah | 35 | 25 | 19 | 10 | 89 |
Packard Lisa | 35 | 15 | 18 | 10 | 78 |
Ryan Sara | 38 | 28 | 18 | 9 | 93 |
Sanfilippo Amanda | 35 | 27 | 19 | 10 | 91 |
Comments |
|
---|---|
Clercx Byron - Score: 89.000 | |
Excellence:
Impact:
Management:
Accessibility:
|
|
Dodds Jed - Score: 78.000 | |
I found very limited detail on the specifics of the program, or evidence of prior accomplishment, to support a determination on the quality. I would have liked to see any of the following: artist and/or instructor bios, lesson plans, examples of PR materials, details on the partnership with ArtServe (mentioned only in passing with no background or context); images of past exhibitions and receptions; description of curatorial process or goals, etc. Another suggestion: if indeed the artistic component is largely provided by ArtServe, perhaps they could help provide specifics for future proposals. Budget is high for limited activity: $16,000 for two instructors? $5,000 for two receptions? No attachments or website that might have addressed the concerns stated above. There's no doubt in my mind that artists of color are generally under resourced, so I genuinely would have liked to support a recommendation for funding, but this proposal didn't reassure me that the organizers had thought things through.
|
|
Harder Lee Ellen - Score: 92.000 | |
{No comments provided.} | |
Krivinchuk Jeremiah - Score: 89.000 | |
Would like to see support materials. | |
Packard Lisa - Score: 78.000 | |
I graded very low on impact because this $50,000 project is going to serve 10 artists at two workshops and two gallery openings and 15 students will be exposed. The bulk of the money is for administrative, i.e., consultants. I feel the impact is woefully small to support the requested amount. | |
Ryan Sara - Score: 93.000 | |
Excellence: Nation's largest and oldest direct service civil rights organization. Would be strengthen by clearer breakdown of goals and the objectives that feed back into them. Impact: Is there a goal you have in mind for economic impact? Management: Culture of diligence. Add economic boost of conference to impact section. Cash reserves, debts, long term liabilities? Wish you would have addressed significant decrease to marketing budget as well as increase to rent. Accessibility: ADA accessible. Any future plans to address other physical or intellectual disabilities? |
|
Sanfilippo Amanda - Score: 91.000 | |
The art component of the program could be more detailed - what support will artists get? |